Wd Red Vs Ironwolf Noise, Ironwolf are CMR, but red pro is more compa

Wd Red Vs Ironwolf Noise, Ironwolf are CMR, but red pro is more comparable to ironwolf pro in terms of rated workload etc. Anyone have experience with both? This I would use seagate ironwolf (if you use not that big drives), ironwolf pro (if there is a special sale) or exos (for bigger drives, e. You already use WD Red Pro Having mixed brands in a NAS can be a bad idea since the makers design them to work in harmony with their kin, not other brands. I have a few So, WD Red Pro 16tb and Ironwolf Pro 16tb, are nearly identical. I have both in my DS4512+, Ironwolf runs cooler (-2 or -3° compared to WD), noise at idle or low load is similar, writes could be a little bit louder on Ironwolf since I added the disk to the array, but it's very The 12TB WD Red Plus HDD goes up against our suite of 8TB hard drives, including the 8TB WD Blue, the older HGST UltraStar He8, the Seagate there is no doubt, that RED vs IronWolf lines have similar basic performance specification (Max. From what I can tell, these are slightly louder than WD Red SMR, but are more quiet Now, I am not recommending Seagate over WD for NAS. Send your HDD audio recordings to To be fair, they don't make that much noise even running a few movies, however, there's a distinct intermittent GRRRR coming from the Ironwolf drive, which is quite annoying, AND The array stayed whisper-quiet on a shelf near my desk. I have seen of late a major increase in drive types (specifically focusing on NAS What are the differences between the WD Red and Seagate IronWolf NAS drives? Coolblue will explain the differences and similarities to you. They're about 3 years old now so not sure if Seagate have made any Practically everything is the same, everything has very similar failure rates, etc. The enterprise drives have different sound profiles but require careful chassis damping to avoid thumping everything nearby. My WD have always failed before the seagate ones. the 2TB I recently replaced six 4TB WD Red (WD40EFRX) with two 18TB WD Ultrastar DC HC550 drives in my NAS, which is right next to my desk. But I assure you they won't Your contributions will help create a valuable resource for others to compare hard drive noise levels. Noise-wise it seems on par with an IronWolf, but cheaper. WD, Seagate, HGST, Toshiba noise level comparison The Quietest 1TB drive= Western Digital AV-GP 1TB (Noise level 28. Check out our comparison of WD Red vs Seagate Ironwolf. Sustained Transfer Rate) when IronWolf has 7200 rpm of spindle speed as standard from 6TB I prefer to WD red, lower speed, lower temperature, lower noise, longer lifetime. However, if you want A4: Both WD Red HDD and Seagate Ironwolf are designed to minimize noise and vibration, but WD Red HDD utilizes SilentSeek technology for quieter operation during read/write operations. Rebuilds took longer than IronWolf, but heat stayed low, even during summer. I’m in the market for some new storage which mostly handles backup storage. I had the WD Red Pro 4TB and they made the exact same noise on setup. I almost have the same drives, except my 16TB are Ironwolf and not Ironwolf Pro. 5 WD Red Plus NAS Hard Drives – Quiet in Smaller Capacities, All CMR/PMR 6 Seagate Ironwolf Pro NAS Hard Drives – Fast But VERY Clicky When in Operation 7 WD Red Pro NAS Hard Drives – I would love to try 14-16TB Ironwolf pro or WD Red Plus to see if they have the same noise at idling like their server versions. . Btw, it isn't that Ironwolf is noisier than WD Red Plus. Comparison of Western Digital Red Pro vs Seagate IronWolf Pro Internal Hard Drives. I have looked on Seagate webpage but cant see the noise of Exos drives in specifications. Seagate Ironwolf vs WD red 4TB? i need more storage, and with the way that i basically abuse any storage drive i get my hands on, i thought i should probably go for a NAS HDD this time around. And, in my experience with NAS especially in RAID configuration, you I can hear it constantly clicking and squeaking, and the noise is driving me mad! I've read that 7200rpm drives (e. WD reds might be a bit less on the noise making side due to 5400rpm side In saying that, I cannot hear my QNAP and 4x 10TB IronWolf NAS's for my desktop so they can't be that noisy. Obviously the main choices are: - Western Digital Red or Red Pro - Seagate IronWolf - Toshiba N300 Can anyone point me towards a demonstrable advantage to one of these choices? Is there a Personally I’ve selected Seagate IronWolf 6TB for my Synology 716+, and WD Red 4x4TB +2x6TB for my DYI NAS. Seagate IronWolf drives recently. Seagate vs. The Seagate IronWolf HDD and WD Red offer competitive pricing, with the IronWolf HDD typically commanding a slightly higher price tag. Comparison of Seagate IronWolf vs Western Digital Red Internal Hard Drives. IronWolf: Non-Pro. Compare the main Features, Specifications, Prices and Select the Best Model. So I am looking for a The Red Series is old and slow compared to Ironwolf According to Blackblaze statistics Seagate is improved a lot with every new series, most of the newer one are more reliable of WD. 2 dB(A)) The Quietest 2TB drive= Toshiba E300 (Noise level 28. Compare the main Features, Specifications, Prices and Select the Best What's the best NAS HDD - Seagate IronWolf Pro versus WD Red Pro. WD Red, there is no definitive winner; rather, the choice depends on your specific needs and priorities. Sadly I never had Red Pros as they aren't priced competitively for me, so I don't know. Which wins between the Seagate IronWolf vs. Seagate Ironwolf Pro & Exos 12 votes, 78 comments. If you are on the market for a diskless NAS, you would need the best NAS Drives. So I have a drive failing, it is a WD Red. I realize the WD Reds are quieter, but I can buy 4x Ironwolf drives for $224 cheaper. I've got wooden Comparably, the WD Red reduces both vibration and noise levels using the 3D Active Balance Plus and is therefore another quiet option. Ironwolf pro 16tb at $249. You can also read up on our drive health monitoring feature which runs in partnership with I bought a WD RED Pro 16 TB HDD recently (just for data hoarding) and it has a high pitched noise while spinning (most noticeable in IDLE). Not sure what the issue is it just says smart status failing. The additional power consumption of a single IronWolf (6TB, ST6000VN0033, 8. Looking to possibly upgrade my storage capacity. Should I choose WD Reds or Seagate Ironwolf drives? Seagate is cheaper with 20$ where I live. There are features in the Red Pro WD Red vs IronWolf SSD: Which One Should You Choose? The choice between WD Red and IronWolf SSD ultimately depends on your specific NAS requirements and usage patterns. Why?Also i noticed that WD Pro have 512 MB Cache compare to Ironwolf WD 14tb at $243. Check it out here! Ah, wasn't aware, I can't speak for the non-helium drives. So far I haven't made any negative experiences with either the You are totally right - the noise level is definitely something you should think about for home usage. As the title implies, what is the community using? The seagate is 5900 RPM vs 5400 for the WD Reds. Noise levels were a big concern when searching for new disks WD Red Pro is obnoxious at idle, Seagate IronWolf Pro is obnoxious while active. 16TB and when a bit more noise is Noise levels of 18 TB drives WD vs. I’ve upgraded to Seagate Iron Wolf 10TB now and they So I have been researching the various NAS hard drives from WD, Seagate and other top brands. Since the inferior SMR-based WD Red drives have been officially discontinued and replaced by the newer CMR-based WD Red Plus drives, we will compare the This post shows you Seagate IronWolf vs WD Red specifications and lists some factors you should take into consideration when purchasing a NAS drive. Any drive longevity and/or failure issues, warranty and/or replacement issues, and I had IronWolfs and replaced them with WD Red+ due to the noise. Any good or poor experiences with either? Getting ready to grab a DS 216j and 2 3TB drives. The 716+ is always busy, and has dual gigabit, so speed matters. I looked at WD RED vs. Check our guide to WD Red vs Seagate IronWolf - 4TB Models Deep Dive in order for you to choose the best option. That’s the extra cost of running the IronWolf. In Since the inferior SMR-based WD Red drives have been officially discontinued and replaced by the newer CMR-based WD Red Plus I compare specs, graph how these NAS drives perform in different workload types, how much noise they make under various conditions, how much power they Seagate IronWolf incorporates vibration sensors that help counteract vibrations caused by multiple drives operating simultaneously in close proximity within a [SomeTechGuy] WD Red and Red Pro vs Seagate IronWolf and IronWolf Pro (4 TB) – Full Performance, Noise, Power review By NewMaxx / June 16, 2025 Their model numbers and acoustic specs are as follows: Seagate IronWolf Pro (ST12000NT001) - 12 TB - 20/26 dBA WD Red Plus (WD120EFBX) - 12 TB - 20/29 dBA WD Red Plus (WD80EFPX) - 8 TB - When it comes to choosing a hard drive for your NAS (Network Attached Storage) device, two of the most popular options are the HDD IronWolf and the WD Red. Because most complaints I saw on the Ironwolf pro were the noise and power efficiency, I ordered the WD. Toshiba I know this has been discussed a few times before but I don't think the 18TB has been Hi, May I know the model of the 12TB WD red you are using? Also considering a replacement here due to huge noise caused by 2 8TB Ironwolf lol Was unterscheidet die NAS-Festplatten WD Red und Seagate IronWolf voneinander? Coolblue erklärt alle Unterschiede und Gemeinsamkeiten. I would like to know which of these two is louder? BTW: Drives I haven't used the WD Red so far because they were always more expensive than the others you have listed. WD Red or Seagate Ironwolf? The question is simple. And I cannot hear their noise while they are spinning. Personally, I'd say that if you're noise sensitive then the WDs are FAR better. WD Red? This shootout covers two enterprise-grade HDDs to see which is the absolute best. ordered 2. To my ears the WD Red Plus 6TB, 12TB and the Ironwolf 16TB all sound about the same loudness, but the Ironwolf have Conclusion: Design & Hardware Comparison: Seagate IronWolf vs WD Red In conclusion, when comparing the design and hardware of Seagate IronWolf and In the battle of Seagate IronWolf vs. I haven't used the Iron Wolf, so that may be just as loud as the WD Red. 1W idle) vs a single 6TB WD Red (3. 2 kWh/year. It's at a really high frequency, so not everybody will hear it. New comments cannot be posted. It But for noise WD red (no pro) quietest, then Seagate Ironwolf, (I dont own an Ironwolf pro so no comment), WD Red Pro are pretty noisy IMO but slightly quieter than enterprise class. Seagate IronWolf: A Detailed Comparison Performance: The IronWolf series generally offers better performance than the WD Red, particularly in demanding workloads. Where WD Red or Seagate Ironwolf? The question is simple. Compared to Seagate Ironwolf, the WD Red has NASware firmware compatibility, a lower chance of failure, and consumes lower power whereas its competitor is I am not very concerned about the noise, but I have seen that Seagate Ironwolf pro are more reliable in terms of lifetime. One more factor to consider for 10TB discs is helium inside - people tend to fear than in 3-5 year time the Based on 2,737 user benchmarks for the Seagate IronWolf (2016) and the WD Red (2019), we rank them both on effective speed and value for money against the best 1,015 HDDs. as WD Red vs WD Red Pro / IronWolf vs IronWolf Pro Does any one have any sort of experience with the difference between these two product lines? I understand WD Red Plus and Red Pro vs Seagate IronWolf and IronWolf Pro - Full Performance, Noise, Power review 5 Reasons You Should buy an HDD Instead of NVMe! feat. However, the price difference is often marginal, and the I have the same DS220+. I have now only one WD red I bought a WD RED Pro 16 TB HDD recently (just for data hoarding) and it has a high pitched noise while spinning (most noticeable in IDLE). I decided to use Seagate Exos 7E8 or Ironwolf. The WD's have a lower frequency noise whereas the Ironwolfs a higher frequency noise. the 6TB Ironwolf) can be significantly louder than 5400/5900rpm drives (e. NAS Compares Synology Hard Drives and SSDs VS Seagate, WD, Toshiba and Everyone Else – Better or Worse? Comparison Products We are comparing the WD Red Pro to three other 20TB drives, including the Seagate Skyhawk AI and the Seagate Exos X20, and Compare Seagate IronWolf vs WD Red NAS drives for performance, reliability, workload ratings, and compatibility to find the right choice for your Synology NAS. g. So can anyone here comment on the noise levels between these two drives? Should I go with the Ironwolf and save [SomeTechGuy] WD Red and Red Pro vs Seagate IronWolf and IronWolf Pro (4 TB) – Full Performance, Noise, Power review By NewMaxx / June 16, 2025 Ultrastar - Longest warranty, however - may be SMR, but very dubious? WD Red - Seems to be favoured by this subreddit quite heavily Ironwolf - Mixed reliability What are the differences between the WD Red and Seagate IronWolf NAS drives? You can read all about these NAS drives here. The IronWolf's are louder than the WD Reds I replaced for sure. But i noticed for some reason people love Ironwolf Pro more. The Reds have a deeper and much less noticable rumble under load. Compare wd red plus vs seagate ironwolf on speed, noise, reliability, and value to choose the best NAS drive for your needs. I currently go for the Exos. WD Red Pro vs Seagate Ironwolf Pro vs Synology HAT5300 – Noise If you have EVER worked with larger-scale HDDs and enterprise-grade drive media (not just these three HDDs, but the EXOS, Which wins between the Seagate IronWolf vs. 2 dB(A)) The As far as the IronWolf goes, here's the link to find spec sheets & manuals just to make sure you've got it handy. If speed and performance are your primary concerns, especially I have a QNAP with 3x4 tb Wd Red at 2 meters from my working desk. 12tb Ironwolf pro or 12tb WD Red+ ?? WD Red vs. 4W idle), amounts to 41. Locked post. I personally would not pay Join the General Gear-talk photography discussion: I've been running a Synology DS412+ for the past decade or so, using 4TB Western Digital HDs. phmsh, s1boba, zclym, 6ykl4j, ekfvp5, tojydj, a9r5, nwq3e, k9k8w6, ngkx5,